Grateful Gatherings Flavors Are Here! SHOP NOW
My Wishlist
Shop By:
Grateful Gatherings
Grateful Gatherings
All products
All products
Best Sellers
Best Sellers
Retiring Soon
Retiring Soon
Sampler Size
Sampler Size
Collagen Peptides
Collagen Peptides
Cookies
Cookies
Dream Cakes
Dream Cakes
Merch
Merch
Gifting
Gifting
Shop By:
Grateful Gatherings Grateful Gatherings All products All products Best Sellers Best Sellers Retiring Soon Retiring Soon Sampler Size Sampler Size Collagen Peptides Collagen Peptides Cookies Cookies Dream Cakes Dream Cakes Merch Merch Gifting Gifting
More Options...
Filter By Tags
Gluten-Free indulgent Protein Macro-Friendly Cookies

More

Squeeze The Day Cookie Squeeze The Day Cookie
Squeeze The Day Cookie
Gluten-Free Options
$ 6.49
Butter My Cup Cookie Butter My Cup Cookie
Butter My Cup Cookie
$ 6.49
Dunk A Spoon Cookie Dunk A Spoon Cookie
Dunk A Spoon Cookie
Gluten-Free Options
$ 6.49
Out of this World Cookie Out of this World Cookie
Out of this World Cookie
$ 6.49
Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Cookie Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Cookie
Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Cookie
$ 6.49
Cake Batter Protein Cookie Cake Batter Protein Cookie
Cake Batter Protein Cookie
$ 7.89
Snickerdoodle Protein Cookie Snickerdoodle Protein Cookie
Snickerdoodle Protein Cookie
$ 7.89
Starberry Blast Cookie Starberry Blast Cookie
Starberry Blast Cookie
Gluten-Free Options
$ 6.49
Fudgin' Around Cookie Fudgin' Around Cookie
Fudgin' Around Cookie
$ 6.49
Peanut Butter Protein Cookie Peanut Butter Protein Cookie
Peanut Butter Protein Cookie
$ 7.89
Double Chocolate Protein Cookie Double Chocolate Protein Cookie
Double Chocolate Protein Cookie
$ 7.89
Lemon Protein Cookie Lemon Protein Cookie
Lemon Protein Cookie
$ 7.89
Gimme S'more Cookie Gimme S'more Cookie
Gimme S'more Cookie
$ 6.49
Chocolate Peanut Butter Protein Cookie Chocolate Peanut Butter Protein Cookie
Chocolate Peanut Butter Protein Cookie
$ 7.89

They Love US

5.0

Delicious!!!

So good, I have to sneak a spoonful when I walk past! Good drizzled over vanilla ice cream.
Katie S
5.0

Favorite Flavor

One of my favorite flavors so far. And as always it is a great pre or post workout snack. It fills you up with lots of protein! I will definitely get this flavor again!
Angela
5.0

Best Yet!

I use to question people who just ate pb by the spoon.. however after sampling a fe this one is the best yet!
A.B.
5.0

Ultimate Favorite!

Out of all the butters I've tried this is my ultimate favorite. It is so good. It was smooth and just tasted like a monster cookie without all the guilt!
Annette
5.0

Best Dang PB ever!!!

I actually add some extra Reece's Pieces to it! I no longer can buy store PB after trying American Dream. Best tasing PB on the market and I keep turning all my friends on to it!
Customer
5.0

YUM.

So oogy gooey and peanut buttery. YUM. Loved the Reese’s pieces and overall texture and flavor. Was scraping the bottom of the container with this one!
Jennifer Brown